Desire for Beauty

This week I have been re-reading Der Tod in Venedig. Thomas Mann has been my favourite German author for several decades now, but my memory of this particular novel had receded almost completely behind the more recent experience of watching Luchino Visconti’s famous movie of 1971. Because I happened to be reading a contemporary novel at the same time – Yann Martel’s Life of Pi (in this case I had seen the movie first) – I was reminded once more that one should never allow one’s standards of quality to be determined by the average level of good and professional writing, but only by the example of truly great authors. No offence intended to Martel, who is competent enough as a writer, but obviously Mann is in a different league altogether. It had been some time since I had read prose of such superior beauty, and the experience brought me straight back to one of my long-term topics of interest and reflection: the nature of beauty and erotic desire. For that, of course, is what Mann’s novel is all about. It tells the deceptively simple story of a famous writer, Gustav Aschenbach, who, following a sudden impulse, decides to escape from his daily work discipline to take a holiday in Venice, where he falls under the fatal spell of an incredibly beautiful teenage boy, Tadzio, who is staying with his family in the same hotel. They never exchange a word. All that Aschenbach does is watching his “idol” from a distance during dinner, on the beach, or during sightseeing tours through the city. When the great man finally succumbs to cholera, while sitting in his chair on the beach, Tadzio is hovering in front of him on the edge between earth, water, and sky, as a luminous figure – Hermes the Psychagoge – beckoning him across the threshold between life and death.
Mann’s lifelong struggle with his homoerotic desires is a key to his oeuvre (see the brilliant biography by Herman Kurzke, which cannot be recommended highly enough, even if it might go just a bit too far in reducing Mann’s Urkram entirely to sexual/erotic repression and sublimation), and his allusions to Plato’s Phaedrus are obvious and wholly explicit. Therefore I decided to re-read that dialogue as well, in a good translation by Robin Waterfield. What I knew best was the famous center part about the four divine frenzies, the chariot of the soul, and its “wings of desire” that start growing in the presence of beauty (cf. Wim Wenders’s movie of that title, known as Der Himmel über Berlin in German). This time I paid more attention to the first parts as well. First Phaedrus recounts a speech by the famous orator Lysias, who argues that an older man who desires a younger boy should take care not to lose his wits by actually falling in love with him, but should keep a cool head and just get what he wants. It’s essentially a cynical argument that highlights the risks and disadvantages of losing one’s reason in the pursuit of sex. Socrates responds by coming up with a speech of his own, which emphasizes that the lover’s erotic passion is disadvantageous and risky to the beloved as well.
Now just imagine. There they are, the older man Socrates and the young attractive Phaedrus, lying in the soft grass under a great tree outside the gates of Athens, far from any prying eyes, and reaching a clear conclusion: one should not give in to the irrational passion of erotic desire! It is precisely at this point that Socrates is interrupted by his inner daimon, who tells him that the tale he has just been telling is utterly false: he has committed a terrible offense against the great God of Love, and should do penance. And so he does, by launching into a speech with an entirely different message, which praises not reasonable restraint but the frenzied state of erotic madness (mania) as a divine condition that leads to true and lasting knowledge. By gazing upon a beautiful human body, the soul is reminded of the absolute beauty that it has once beheld when it was still travelling in the company of the gods along the outer rim of the heaven. From there it could gaze into the region beyond heaven, which “has never yet been adequately described in any of our earthly poets’ compositions, nor will it ever be”: this is the home of absolute unchanging and everlasting beauty, of which the passing images of corporeal beauty in this temporal world can give only a reflection. This beauty is the proper divine nourishment for the wings of the soul: at the sight of a beautiful human body, they spontaneously begin to grow, getting ready to carry the soul upwards back to its divine origin.
It’s a splendid narrative, compellingly beautiful in its very analysis of beauty. Reading Plato’s Phaedrus again, in conjunction with Thomas Mann Tod in Venedig, I couldn’t help musing about the incredible power of ideas. The impact of this relatively short dialogue can hardly be overstated, and regardless of its beauty (or, rather, because of it?) it must be admitted that its effects have been far from just positive. Firstly, Plato’s insistence that we must find beauty beyond the body has given legitimacy to Christian obsessions with sex and sin, at least since Augustine, leading to pervasive mechanisms of repression and sublimation that are the object of psychoanalysis and remain omnipresent in our society to the present day. Secondly, the narrative simply denies beauty to women; and while this would eventually be corrected, when Platonism got heterosexualized into a veritable “religion of beauty in woman” – medieval chivalric ideals of “courtly love”, some currents of Sufism, Renaissance Platonism after Ficino, Romanticism – it remains doubtful, to say the least, whether the masculine gaze can at all be translated into a feminine gaze on corporeal beauty (whether masculine or feminine) – or whether it should. And finally, the Platonic ideal of love has led to an implicit “complicity with death” at least since German Romanticism: perhaps beginning with Justinus Kerner (an underestimated pioneer: see pp. 236-237 here), eros has been implicated with illness and death, because only through dissolution of the body is it supposed to be possible for the soul to reach its true destiny. Nobody knew this better than Thomas Mann himself, for not just Tod in Venedig but also its splendid hetero-erotic counterpart Tristan, and indeed his entire oeuvre – particularly Der Zauberberg and Doktor Faustus, which really diagnose the cultural pathologies underlying World War I and II respectively – can be read as testimony to a persistent struggle with the human, moral, and ultimately political implications of Platonic eros. There is something awe-inspiring (literally numinous) in the realization that, in some very real sense, so much of the essential drama of Western culture may have its origin in a frenzied conversation between two Greek philosophers, lying under a shady tree on a lazy afternoon, talking about love.

Comments

  1. It has been many years since I have seen the Visconti film "Death in Venice," but as I recall, Tadzio's elements of decay--his rotten teeth--were eliminated from the character. In its place we have instead a sanitized bland but blonde anondyne youth to help cover over the anguish of an old man's dying moments. No one ultimately escapes the empery of death and decay.

    I would not expect to see any bows to Plato or to Thomas Mann in the recent HBO film about Liberace, "Behind the Candelabra," but the issues about sexual desire between the old and the young obviously have their parallels. In the latter case, the distant but absorbing gaze of Gustav Aschenbach is merely the starting point of the affair. It is almost instantly transformed into a desire to remake the younger person into a simalcrum of the older man's younger and idealized self-image. Yet it is not a simple case of predator and prey: both are parties, however unequal, to the game that unfolds. These are merely stopgap efforts however, as thanatos outruns eros for both Aschenbach and Liberace, and for us all.

    I recall reading the Thomas Mann novella for the first time winter quarter of my freshman year at the University of Chicago, while a horrible flu/cold swept over our dormitory. Alas, I was not present for the "Greek Thought and Literature" lecture when a freshman, when queried about how the class felt about the homosexuality in "The Symposium" replied with utter assurance that it was a metaphor for something else, for the Greeks were far too smart to do anything like that…

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mr. Hanegraaff,

    Thank you again for an interesting read. Another reason to brush up my German... :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.
    brazilian wax NYC

    ReplyDelete
  4. I added it to my favorites blog site list and will be checking back soon.
    Spa in Manhattan

    ReplyDelete
  5. I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? THANKS!
    Cheap spa packages NYC

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that thanks for the valuabe information and insights you have so provided here.
    Mothers Day Spa Special NY

    ReplyDelete
  7. Very useful info. Hope to see more posts soon!.
    seo backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  8. Before you jump into this post you buy backlinks
    need to know this is NOT a guide on how to obtain backlinks. There are a ton of great resources on that ...

    ReplyDelete

  9. Healthisgod is the only complete health and wellness website that you may describe as it yours. We created a site that introduces the collection of health and lifestyle information supported by reliable content providers and genuine user reviews. This is a sincere effort on our part to bring forth a user experience which is engaging, moving, and interactive. Visit for more- Health is God

    ReplyDelete
  10. I’ve been writing essays for how many years and today I’m more on academic essay writing and I’m happy to be like my dad, a professional writer..Read more Kim kardashian sex tape and Mia Khalifa Sex video and Sunny Leone Sexy Movie

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nutra Trials defines personal characteristics of different health products including skincare, weight loss, muscle and male enhancement. The study presented here is briefly described for reader convenience and to deliver them assurance with health standards. The best possible answers are given here regarding the selection of an ideal supplement or cream or serum that possibly remains to be safe for health and do not cause any side effects.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It is a great job, I like your posts and wish you all the best. and I hope you continue this job well.
    NutraT line

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hello, I am thomus jons thank you for this informative post. That is a great job. Wish you more success.Thank you so much and for you all the best. Takes Down
    123movies

    ReplyDelete
  14. TecSmash is your ultimate source of Technology news and Make Money Online product reviews. We research and review all Tech, MMO, Biz Opp and IM products.
    Tecsmash

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. HealRun is a health news blog we provide the latest news about health, Drugs and latest Diseases and conditions. We update our users with health tips and health products reviews. If you want to know any information about health or health product (Side Effects & Benefits) Feel Free To ask HealRun Support Team.

      Delete
  15. Here is our FB SociCake Review, in which I have revealed the good, bad and ugly about Mario Browns FB SociCake Facebook Marketing Tool. socicake review

    ReplyDelete
  16. Pilpedia is supplying 100 percent original and accurate information at each moment of time around our site and merchandise, and the intent is to improve the usage of good and pure health supplement. For More Info please visit Pilpedia online store.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Supplements For Fitness fish oil. If these side effects occur, it is best to consult a health professional. You would have to stop taking fish oil supplements or it could mean other serious diseases.

    https://www.supplementsforfitness.com/

    ReplyDelete
  18. We are here to give you a complete review on the Parallel Profit project by Steve Clayton and Aidan Booth. If you are someone from the field you would already be familiar with these two names, for those of who are new. Parallel Profits Review

    ReplyDelete
  19. WiredReach.org is dedicated to bring you the best in Internet Marketing, Blogging and the entire Make Money Online spectrum. We are your finest source of info.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Revuesdefaits defines personal characteristics of various health merchandise together with skincare, weight loss, muscle and male enhancement. The study presented here is briefly described for reader convenience and to deliver them assurance with health standards. The best potential answers are given here concerning the selection of a perfect supplement or cream or serum that presumably remains to be safe for health and do not cause any facet effects.

    http://revuesdefaits.fr/vital-keto/

    https://www.facebook.com/Revues-De-Faits-2466562093413723/

    ReplyDelete
  21. Buyers Reviews defines personal characteristics of different health products including skincare, weightloss, muscle and male enhancement.Buyers Reviews is supplying 100% original and accurate information at each moment of time around our site and merchandise, and the intent is to improve the usage of good and pure health supplement.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Testo Ultra :Apparemment, tu n’as pas à faire ça. Il y a plusieurs raisons pour la popularité des régimes de booster de testostérone. Comment les individus réalisent des séminaires de luxe testostérone Booster régimes?

    http://revuesdefaits.fr/testoultra/

    ReplyDelete
  23. The Probiotic supplement helps to balance good bacteria and in this regard, Probiotic t 50 review is creating buzz. How far is the supplement reliable and worth considering, you will come to know about it here.

    ReplyDelete
  24. New You Keto -That is how to cure worrying bordering on weight Lose. The more circles learn with regard to weight Loss Supplement, the more they will start to use Keto. Perhaps you're on to something. Help! weight Loss Tips might become a mystery for a smattering of wanderers. This has an authentic flavor. As we know, don't be forgotten. Chances are that they will be mostly older women but I'd like to see signs that lovers understand they've got only a limited chance with Keto.

    https://www.supplementwebmd.com/new-you-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Constantly CBD - This is a reasonable contender. Wellness has the accuracy and precision you need. There are some daily expenses to ponder. It was wasteful. Many Wellness blogs have forums where you can locate information. If you want to be in on conversations with reference to Wellness you have to understand Wellness.

    https://www.tophealthychat.com/constantly-cbd-oil/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Alka Tone Keto - Anyway, "I would rather have a bottle in front of me, than a frontal lobotomy." and here's the case in point. I do agree that you shouldn't use Weight Loss Diets in this way. We can't think of a better program. That will be sort of a melding between the explanation and that in order that in the wake of Weight Loss Tips some things was different.

    http://www.sharktankdiets.com/alka-tone-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  27. Believing These 5 Myths About Adtrics Academy Keeps You From Growing - https://www.reviewengin.com/adtrics-academy-review/

    ReplyDelete
  28. Suplementarios >>> La autenticidad de nuestro sitio web es claramente visible a través de salud y estado fisico con el nombre mencionado en él. Tenemos el mejor producto relacionado con la salud aquí y la tendencia a ofrecer nuestro mejor apoyo a los huéspedes que buscan detalles de los suplementos y comparaciones entre ellos. Para más información amable >>> http://suplementarios.es/

    http://suplementarios.es/sizeplus/

    http://suplementarios.es/keto-guru/

    ReplyDelete
  29. Believing These 9 Myths About Forex Duality Keeps You From Growing - https://www.reviewengin.com/forex-duality-review/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Pure Life Keto fat burner supplement is a completely new product that is falling right into the hype keto diet trend. It seems like everybody talks about this amazing diet supplement as it saved their obesity issues. Ketosis is seen as pleasing because it encourages the body to use excessive stored fat as fuel. Kindly Visit on Pure life Keto Weight Loss Supplement

    ReplyDelete
  31. Cellogica is a premium quality day and night cream designed to reduce the symptoms of aging, including wrinkles and crow’s feet. The product leverages the power of an exclusive formula that incorporates the MAC-5 complex and more. As a result, it stimulates collagen production, helps retain moisture, soften lines and wrinkles, and shrink pores. Additionally, Cellogica helps firm the skin. Kindly Visit on Cellogica Cream

    ReplyDelete
  32. Your blog is so informative... keep up the good work...
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi, Thank you for sharing such a wonderful information. Check also here
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  34. Your mode of describing the whole thing in this piece of writing is actually fastidious, every one can easily understand it, Thanks a lot.
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  35. Thanks for sharing your info. I truly appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further write ups thank you once again.               
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  36. Great Post! You Shared Everything About The Topic. Thanks Again! Times For Education - Everyday News Portal Of Education. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  37. TimesForEducation.com - Everyday News Portal Of Education

    TimesForEducation
    https://timesforeducation.com/

    TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

    ===========================================================

    normal comment. TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

    normal comment. TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  38. Nice Post Share……Keep Shareing!!               
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi to all, the contents existing at this site are actually remarkable for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.               
    https://care2fit.com

    ReplyDelete
  40. Absolutely love your creative idea! Can I share your post on my facebook page?I’m always happy to share great Information,
    Keto BodyTone

    ReplyDelete

  41. Thanks for share this valuable post TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  42. Why people still use to read news papers when in this technological world all is accessible on web?
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  43. This is based on the analysis of hundreds of high performance ads on Facebook and YouTube, and makes it easy to make a high convert ad copy quickly. Paid traffic: - Paid traffic generally refers to buying traffic from advertising network. Facebook advertising is a great tool for growing your business. Blogging) which has no limit on how many people read my stuff, affiliate commissions, etc. It is an essential part of these days if we are using affiliate products in paid advertisements. PPC advertising supplies immediate web traffic by putting you at leading placements on search engines. Their program policies state that publishers are prohibited from utilizing traffic (in any form, even email marketing) that directly tell users to click. It has been created on the analytics of several ads that perform pretty well on YouTube and Facebook.

    PPC, like anything else, has a learning curve, and as you run more campaigns, you'll learn more about the combination of ad networks and content pieces that works best for your audience. Google and Bing use bids to determine how high your ads appear in the search results, so if your keyword bid is lower amongst other bidders, your ad will not achieve a favourable position in the search results. I know how powerful affiliate marketing can be when it's done the right way, and I know what a difference it can make for you and your audience when you're promoting products and services that can really help them out. Retargeting ads typically bring up thoughts of ads designed to bring visitors back to a specific product page after engaging with that content or adding it to their cart but not completing the purchase. https://www.reviewengin.com/overnight-freedom-review/


    ReplyDelete
  44. Why people still use to read news papers when in this technological world all is accessible on web?
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  45. Incredible points. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the good spirit.
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  46. For most up-to-date news you have to go to see web and on the web I found this website as a finest website for latest updates.
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  47. Hi to all, the contents existing at this site are actually remarkable for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.
    https://www.drozus.com

    ReplyDelete
  48. This is very interesting. thanks for that. we need more sites like this.
    Morgan @ Gowell Health Tips

    ReplyDelete
  49. TecSmash is your ultimate source of Technology news and Make Money Online product reviews. We research and review all Tech, MMO, Biz Opp and IM products.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Just like you will find in most of the 28 Day Keto Challenge Review on the internet, this guide narrows down to the precise understanding of everything that goes into eliminating carbs from your diet.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts